If there is one thing that’s nice about Twins GM Bill Smith, its that he doesn’t share the same worldview as Ron Gardenhire. Terry Ryan definitely did. Ryan often stood pat at the deadline, thinking that Gardy had a good handle on things, in the short term and that a disruption of the pipeline from the minors would be detrimental to the Twins long term. Then the bullpen would fall apart and the Twins would either miss the playoffs or lose in the first round because they couldn’t score any runs.
Now the new GM Smith has proven that, if he doesn’t necessarily agree with Gardy’s philosophies on baseball, he can mitigate some of Gardenhire’s problem areas so it’s not such a disaster. Let’s take a look at three examples from the past year, and what ones might come into play at the deadline this year.
1) Gardenhire often favors defense to the detriment of offense: One of the first things that Smith did when he took over was acquire Delmon Young. Later, Carlos Gomez and his atrocious plate approach was brought in from New York in the Johan Santana trade. Gomez was a speedy, top flight defender, whereas Young was to be one of the top right handed hitters in a lefty heavy lineup. Well, Denard Span emerged as a good center field defender, which sort of ended the need for Gomez’s glove… until Gardy started putting Span in left field and benching Young. Young’s numbers faltered, but he showed he was at his best when he got extended playing time. Over the offseason, Gomez was traded to the Brewers for JJ Hardy, and Young HAS to play every day. On a team with Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau, he is leading the squad in batting average and RBI.
Will this factor into the deadline: Probably not
Gardenhire overmanages his bullpen: Matt Guerrier continuously leads the AL in appearances, and most other pitchers come in regularly for an inning or less. All that warming up and entering games drains a player, and that was the case last year (and every year, but Smith was in charge last year), so to stave off the bullpen fatigue, he added Jon Rauch and Ron Mahay, who if nothing else prevented Matt Guerrier’s arm from falling off.
Will this factor into the deadline: It probably will every year, though the Twins haven’t gone to the minors much for pitching help. Still, don’t be surprised if some relief help is added in Minnesota.
In Gardy’s world, a middle infielder will ALWAYS bat 2nd: This is problematic, because even if you take away terrible hitting middle infielders, another one will take his place. Last year with Nick Punto batting 2nd all season, Smith grabbed Orlando Cabrera from the A’s, and he was immediately put into the 2 spot. Over the offseason, he signed Orlando Hudson who has hit 2nd most of the year, keeping Punto at the bottom of the lineup where he belongs. This problem is usually solved with an Orlando.
Will this factor into the deadline: It wouldn’t have, until Hudson went on the DL. Now Alexi Casilla has taken his spot on the field and in the lineup. The trade doesn’t need to be for an elite infielder, just a backup with a high OBP. This is why Ty Wigginton keeps coming up in Twins rumors.
Will the Twins make any deals at the deadline this year? Probably, if only to keep Gardenhire from himself.
[UPDATE] Well, well well… The Twins have done exactly what my theorizing would have suggested, adding depth to their bullpen to prevent an implosion at the hands of Gardenhire. Well done, Smith. Well done. No on to the middle infield…











